Spain Plans Small Raid on Saver's Deposits

***Please feel free to leave comments or ask questions at the bottom of the article. We will reply or will write a special article to answer your questions.***


With the negative publicity and real risks being generated by the raid on savings in Cyprus, you would almost think that policy leaders would see the danger in even talking about more raids on savers.



Minister Cristobal Montoro (right)
seen in this photo with an American industrialist
 - Photo from PBS.org

Not in Spain.  Believe it or not, the Spanish government is planning a depositors levy that will take some 0.1% to 0.2% from the banks based on their total level of deposits.  The difference appears to be that it will be the banks that have to pay the levy, rather than the money being taken from individual accounts.  The new measures will take effect in a matter of weeks. 

According to Treasury Minister Cristóbal Montoro, this levy will raise some 1.5 to 3 billion Euros.  This will help “impose order in the Spanish banking system” says the Minister without explaining how this will help.

We will only take this much - at least the first time! 
Photo by CBC.ca

Like any good politician, Mr Montoro says this is not his idea, but rather he is doing this to remain compliant with the wishes of the European Commission.  Again, no explanation of how this will keep the EC happy.

QUESTION:  Where will the banks get the 3 billion Euros to pay this new tax which will be based on deposits? 

ANSWER:  Depositors?  Stand by for more fees and lower service levels in Spanish banks as the banks find a way to pay this new tax. 

One thing is clear.  If you are a saver and you have money, the highly indebted governments and banks will find a way of getting it.

This is economics for the rest of us.  Savers beware everywhere!

 

 

(For more on what the Brits and the Americans are planning for their depositors, see http://tiny.cc/z4jcuw ) 

(For more on what is happening to Cyprus savers, see http://tinyurl.com/b2hqds6)

Spain and Cyprus - Savers Get Robbed Either Way

Warning: The bankers and the government will get your savings one way or another.

Note the protest sign at top:  Banks in Spain cheat on you!

BBC News - Getty Images

 

If you think Cyprus is a mess and the people there might get their savings accounts raided, wait until you see what the bankers and the government have just done in Spain.

Following the housing market crash in Spain, a number of regional banks were rapidly moving towards bankruptcy.  As a means of fixing this problem, the Spanish government and its central bank orchestrated a 2010 scheme whereby seven of the banks would be rolled into one and recapitalized.

As a means of raising cash for this new creation to be known as “Bankia” Spanish citizens were told by their local bankers that they could buy shares. Based on years of trust and government approval, some 350,000 Spanish citizens sank their hard earned cash into the new shares.

The Bankia shares were valued at 3.75 Euros and the citizens were told the bank would have a rough start followed by a return to profitability in a relatively short time.  Indeed, the bank announced that for 2011 it would make a small profit of 309 million Euros.

Small problem however... 

Instead of making some 300 million Euros as announced, the bank later re-estimated its accounts and stated that it would lose approximately 3 BILLION Euros instead. 

On top of all of that, the bailed out bank would need to be bailed out again. 

The upshot for the Spanish citizens was that their 3.75 Euro shares were today valuated at – get this -.01 Euros or one cent apiece.  To add insult to injury, the Spanish government has also announced there will be a sort of inverse stock split of 100 to 1. 

In other words, for every 100 shares you have in Bankia, they will now be turned into one share that will be worth 1 Euro. 

Spanish savers (350,000 of them) were given a major haircut. Their 3.75 a piece share actually bought them 1 cents worth of value. 

How is that for a haircut? 

There is a lesson in this. Savers have money.  And when the bankers and the governments decided they need it – they will take it one way or another. 

In Cyprus, the savers (and the non-resident Russians) may lose some of their money in an involuntary onetime tax or levy. In Spain, the savers were just fleeced the old fashioned way by con artists. 

This is economics for the rest of us.  Savers beware no matter where you are!